ICJ’s Rohingya verdict is not enough
The tragedy of the Rohingya is that despite a verdict from the world’s highest court, their suffering is likely to persist. The least that countries can do is put pressure on Myanmar to implement the court’s orders, on internal investigations, restitution and compensation.
The ruling by the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the world’s highest court, on Myanmar’s 2016-17 military campaign against its Rohingya minority marks the first time a state has been found guilty of genocide and of violating the 1948 Genocide Convention. It provides a measure of justice to a community that has long faced persecution in Myanmar, where a 1982 citizenship law effectively rendered the vast majority of Rohingya stateless. Although they have endured repeated phases of violence over the decades, the 2017 military “clearance operations” in northern Rakhine State involved sexual violence and mass killings, driving more than 7,00,000 into neighbouring Bangladesh. Proving genocide has always been difficult because prosecutors must establish “specific intent” (dolus specialis). In 2007, the ICJ found that Serbia had failed to prevent genocide in Srebrenica in 1995, but had not directly committed it. But in the Rohingya case brought forth by The Gambia, the ICJ concluded that “genocidal intent is the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the evidence”. The Myanmar ruling could have implications for the ongoing case filed by South Africa against Israel in the same court for the latter’s actions in Gaza.
The outcome of the verdict, however, may not go beyond a moral victory. Only the UN Security Council can enforce it, but Russia and China — countries that have armed Myanmar’s junta and provided diplomatic backing — hold veto powers. Further, international institutions are under relentless attack from the big powers. On the day of the ICJ verdict, the US, Russia and China jointly announced that the UN needed “reform” and that the “International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction”. Meanwhile, countries that have sheltered the Rohingya are becoming less welcoming. Bangladesh, which hosts about 1.2 million Rohingya, has never formally recognised them as refugees and restricts their movement and employment. Aid is shrinking, and living conditions in the camps are deteriorating. Malaysia has begun sending Rohingya victims back to Myanmar — it has now announced plans to resettle 10,000 of them in Turkey. India, too, has carried out expulsions.
The tragedy of the Rohingya is that despite a verdict from the world’s highest court, their suffering is likely to persist. The least that countries can do is put pressure on Myanmar to implement the court’s orders, on internal investigations, restitution and compensation.